GeezerVison

LLM Description written by Claude Code:claude-opus-5-5

Fixes #1511

Summary

In an npm workspace under install-strategy=nested, member a uses registry [email protected] and member b depends on a file: directory that holds the same release. A vendored scan --vex and a standalone vex both said not_affected, and vendor --check passed. But b's copy is a symlink to that directory, which no rewrite reaches, so it stays unpatched.

After this PR:

• VEX: the vendored run's in-run --vex and a standalone vex attest nothing. They warn patched_ref_unattributable and name packages/b/node_modules/left-pad, as they already did for the file: tarball and URL shapes. Hosted mode has refused this shape since Fix npm file: copy attested by in-run VEX (#1481) #1482.
• vendor --check: fails with copy unpatched: … naming that lock entry. Before this PR it passed. Without the second commit it would have failed with the false "wiring missing … re-run socket-patch vendor".

Root cause

vex::discover::npm::drop_non_registry_installs withholds a Socket-wired ref when a non-registry copy of the same name@version installs beside it. It read the copy's identity only from the entry's version. npm records a file: directory dependency as a versionless link entry ("resolved": "lpdir", "link": true), and only the directory's own entry carries the version. So the loop skipped it and the ref stayed attested. #1482 added that link → source lookup (npm_link_source_identity) to the hosted rewriter only. Discovery, which vendored VEX and vendor --check read, never got it.

Changes

1. npm_link_source_identity moves from patch/redirect/mod.rs to vendor::npm_origin, next to npm_non_registry_entries. It now takes the link entry rather than a JSON pointer. The hosted rewriter and discovery both call it.
2. Discovery resolves a versionless link entry that npm installs from a file: spec through that lookup. As in the hosted rewriter, only entries in npm_non_registry_entries qualify, so a plain workspace-member link is still first-party source.
3. New Discovery::vendored_shadow: when a vendored claim died because its ref was moved to shadowed (an unpatched copy beside it), vendor --check quotes the diagnostic that names the copy. It no longer says nothing wires the artifact or tells the user to re-vendor. This also corrects the message for the existing bundled / git / url / file: tarball shapes. CLI_CONTRACT.md's vendor --check paragraph documents the new copy unpatched reason.

Tests (red → green)

Not changed (review notes)

• The vendored rewriter still labels the file: directory's own source entry vendor_workspace_member_skipped. That label comes from npm vendored refuses a registry package with vendor_workspace_member whenever a local file: directory (or workspace member) has the same name@version, and the hosted→vendored takeover then un-hosts it, leaving it unpatched #688 and is documented in the contract's error-code table, and namesake_local_directory_does_not_block_registry_copies pins it. Renaming it to a loud vendor_non_registry_entry_skipped is a contract change, so I've left it as a possible follow-up. The run's own --vex warning and vendor --check now name the unpatched copy, so the outcome is no longer silent.
• /code-review high flagged a scoped (@scope/name) folder-name case with no test. That branch of npm_link_source_identity is unchanged code from Fix npm file: copy attested by in-run VEX (#1481) #1482.

Local verification (head 7b7f58c)

• cargo fmt --all -- --check: clean. cargo clippy --workspace --all-features -- -D warnings: clean.
• cargo test --workspace --all-features (run in chunks because of the sandbox's disk allowance): every suite passes except 10 write-failure tests that rely on read-only permissions (relax_loop_must_not_traverse_symlinked_root, an_unremovable_hidden_lock_keeps_every_store_entry, wire_write_failure_*, wire_failure_rolls_back_*, *_state_write_failure_*, partial_lockfile_write_failure_*, redirect_json_mode_write_failures_*, scan_redirect_vlt_heal_invalidation_failure_warns). The sandbox runs as root, which bypasses those permissions. The tests are unrelated to this diff, and CI runs them as a non-root user.
• e2e_vendor_npm_build and e2e_redirect_npm_build with --include-ignored on real npm 10.9.4: 36 and 43 passed.
• /code-review high ran on the diff. Fixed from it: the vendor --check false "wiring missing" diagnosis, the link lookup gated to file: entries, the vacuous in-run VEX assertion, the missing workspace-member control, and the split name derivation. Not fixed, with reasons under "Not changed".
• No wrapper changes needed: npm/, pypi/ and gem/ only dispatch to the binary.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Generated by Claude Code