GeezerVison

Unbound methods (i.e. functions) become bound methods when regularly accessed as instance attributes. From the class level, the contract of Python is that the unbound method can be called like a function (the first argument to the call will be used as the conventional self) and the call will execute directly (no bound method in between). Following the contract, a natural expectation is that when generic methods are called as class attributes, the second argument will be used for dispatching, not the first (the conventional self).

To support descriptors like classmethod (that bind to something else than the instance), arguments are shifted by one even if __get__ method returns a method that is bound to a different object than the original self (_singledispatchmethod_get._obj). If one wants to receive that self in an arbitrary bound method as a regular argument, the workaround is easy: return a partial(bound method) to hack the check.

This is a low risk bugfix. The patch is meant to fix the following program:

class C:
   @singledispatchmethod
   def generic(self, x: object):
       return "generic"

   @generic.register
   def special(self, x: int):
       return "special"

assert C.generic(C(), 1) == "generic"  # should be "special"

• Issue: singledispatchmethod dispatches on first argument to instance-bindable method called from class level #143535